帖子初期反响还可以,直到收到了一条评论:I can't Read the AI posts anymore it feel so pointless and empty
然后就崩了,他的点赞蹭蹭蹭往上涨,但帖子点赞跌到 0 ,然后帖子被版主删了。
我们有在帖子下讨论,他的观点:
Sadly after reading soo many posts and going though soo many repos of new plug-ins it is tiring. I do software for a living. All theese projects have in common is bad practices, bad maintainability and so much more. If it's something people need and rely on but for the creator it's just an afternoon project wich is easily abandoned it leads to bad faith in the software. Maintaining a project is time intensive. If a new version of obsidian breaks the plug-in but the maintainer nolonger does any work it leads to many sad users.
Additionally I have no faith in the software delivered. It could have a major exploit ore be harmful, even if not intentionally. But not be found because the maintainer has no clue how the code actually works.
Good things take time. It takes so much time to test and make sure the program is reliable that I doubt any project I see with is vibe coded.
The AI has glaring flaws if you know the subject you're using it for. But if you're not knowledgeable it all looks correct but really is full of half truths.
大致意思就是 ai 写的代码粗制滥造,并且容易弃更、以及未知的漏洞。最后说的行内人一看就知道是 ai 写的,外行人就半信半疑(我也是靠翻译的,不确定是不是这个意思)。
我给他回的观点:
AI 是工具,消除了阶级,不对等的问题,以至于普通人也能制作自己的工具,减少了时间和成本,而且对于普通软件来讲,够用了就行。至于担心维护问题,这个插件本来就是开源的,克隆下来在自己 ai 修改下就行了呗。当然我也反对在高风险项目中使用没有 reveiw 的代码(至少要加一层保障)。
随后帖子被删了,我没有再回复了。
想问下大家对 ai 写代码是什么看法?为什么感觉有很大一部分人厌恶 vibe coding ?

